News
AI Automation: Will It Create a Permanent Underclass?
Source: newyorker.com
Published on October 9, 2025
Updated on October 9, 2025

AI Automation Raises Fears of a 'Permanent Underclass'
The rapid advancement of AI automation is sparking both excitement and concern across the tech industry. As AI continues to automate tasks once performed by humans, experts warn that a 'permanent underclass' of unemployable individuals could emerge, fundamentally reshaping the job market and the future of work.
Silicon Valley insiders have begun to sound the alarm, cautioning that AI’s ability to outperform humans in various sectors could lead to widespread job displacement. Venture capitalist Jayden Clark has satirically highlighted this anxiety, suggesting that AI could soon render large portions of the workforce obsolete. Leopold Aschenbrenner, a prominent researcher, echoes this sentiment, predicting that AI could surpass human capabilities in key areas by as early as 2027.
The Impact of AI on the Job Market
AI is already disrupting several industries, from content creation on social media to automating tasks in corporate software. This shift has led to a noticeable slowdown in hiring, particularly for entry-level positions. Nate Soares, an AI pessimist, notes that while the timeline for full automation remains uncertain, its impact on jobs is inevitable.
Entry-level software engineers are among the most affected. Jasmine Sun, an industry analyst, observes that there is now a stark divide: some engineers secure high-paying roles, while others struggle to find employment. The new ideal employee is increasingly expected to be hyper-productive, mirroring the efficiency of AI systems. Ironically, escaping the potential 'underclass' may require adopting a bot-like work ethic.
Tech Leaders Lack a Coherent Vision for the Future
Despite the growing concerns, many tech leaders lack a clear plan for addressing the economic implications of AI automation. Sun points out that discussions around wealth redistribution or universal basic income are largely absent. This raises critical questions about the future of those displaced by AI and what viable alternatives will exist for them.
As people explore strategies to secure their livelihoods, some are turning to trades or industries less susceptible to automation, such as plumbing or agriculture. Others are considering self-sufficiency or communal living as a means to escape the reach of technology. However, collective action may prove challenging in an era dominated by AI-driven media and algorithms.
The Future of Work in an AI-Driven World
The future of work remains uncertain as AI continues to advance. While some experts predict a dystopian scenario where a 'permanent underclass' emerges, others see opportunities for new industries and roles to develop. What is clear, however, is that the job market will undergo significant changes, and adaptation will be key to navigating this new landscape.
As AI automation becomes more prevalent, society will need to confront the ethical, economic, and social challenges it presents. The choices made today will shape the future of work for generations to come.