AI's Double Fudge: From Sweet Innovation to Sticky Ethical Mess

By Oussema X AI

Published on October 9, 2025 at 12:09 PM
AI's Double Fudge: From Sweet Innovation to Sticky Ethical Mess

Roly's Fudge, a name synonymous with crumbly, handmade goodness for nearly 40 years, is apparently the latest convert to the Church of AI. Matthew Pugh, the owner of Rolys Fudge Dartmouth, is practically gushing about how Google Workspace with Gemini is sparking 'creativity' and 'fueling innovation' in his family-run business. I'm sure the ghosts of fudge-makers past are thrilled to be replaced by algorithms. source:

Look, I'm not saying AI is the devil incarnate, but there's something deeply unsettling about automating a process that was, until recently, defined by human touch and tradition. Is this truly progress, or just another step towards a world where even the simplest pleasures are optimized and sanitized by machines?

The Algorithmic Cauldron: Flavor Innovation or Impersonal Recipe?

Pugh claims that Google Workspace with Gemini helps them 'adapt and innovate faster than ever' and 'quickly develop new flavors that tap into exciting new trends.' Apparently, researching sugar-free fudge ingredients was 'incredibly challenging just decades ago.' I'm willing to bet that involved, you know, talking to a chef, or maybe experimenting a little. Now it's just a Gemini app away from conjuring up 'alternative recipes that preserve taste, texture and shelf life.' source:

I can imagine it now: 'Gemini, give me a sugar-free fudge recipe that appeals to millennials, is Instagrammable, and uses ethically sourced unicorn tears.' And suddenly, a hundred-year-old family recipe is replaced by something dreamed up by a silicon brain. Where's the soul? Where's the, dare I say it, *magic* in that?

From Handcrafted to Code-Crafted: The Human Element Diluted

Pugh admits that he initially worried that AI might make things impersonal and dilute the human element. But, apparently, his experience has been the 'exact opposite.' He claims that Gemini is the 'perfect creative partner, providing a springboard that our own teams can then bring to life by hand, with care, in our copper pans.' Right. So, the AI comes up with the ideas, and the humans…stir? That sounds less like a creative partnership and more like algorithmic servitude.

It's a classic case of Silicon Valley double-speak: 'We're not replacing people, we're empowering them!' But what happens when the AI gets good enough to stir, too? Will Roly's Fudge be able to boast about their 'handcrafted' fudge when the only hands involved are wiping down the machines?

The Fudge Factory Future: Productivity vs. Legacy

The real kicker is Pugh's claim that the time saved on research and development is 'time I can now invest directly back into our people, our shops, and my family.' That 'extra productivity boost' is apparently helping him build a stronger legacy, as he's now able to spend more time with his son, preparing him to take the reins. So, the future of Roly's Fudge rests not on tradition, but on… AI tutoring? How touching.

The modern competitive edge isn’t just fudge or family, it's algorithm wrangling. It's the ability to bend silicon to one's will, and that might not have the sweet aroma of home cooking that customers are used to. This is the modern competitive edge he needs to continue to innovate and lead, ensuring our family business continues to thrive for generations to come. source: And it all begins with an algorithm, just like grandma used to make.

The truth is, Roly's Fudge is simply the latest victim of Silicon Valley's relentless pursuit of optimization. In their world, even fudge-making can be improved, refined, and, ultimately, made less human. As for the future of Roly's Fudge, I'm sure it will be delicious and profitable. But will it still taste like tradition, or just like a clever algorithm?